I identify as Hispanic. But I wondered today, when did we start thinking of ourselves as identifying as this or that rather than just being what we are. It happened in layers. The word was old, but the self-labeling sense (“I identify as X”) mostly dates from the 1990s and spread widely in the 2000s and 2010s. Before the 1950s, “Identity” was mainly a term in philosophy and logic. Freud’s idea of “identification” with another person goes back to the 1920s, but it was about attachment, not labeling yourself. In the 1950s, The notion of “identity crisis” made the word popular in psychology. In the 1960s–70s, identity became a political term. The term “gender identity” came into clinical use around 1964. Around 1970 the US Census moved to people filling in their own forms, so race was increasingly self-reported. Groups also began choosing their own names: the term “Asian American” was created in 1968, according to activists and academics. By the early 1970s, identity migrated into the political arena, and “identity politics” followed later in the decade. From the 1990s onward, people began using “identify as” on its own, with no “myself,” to mean “see myself as.” A 2011 Grammarphobia column said the usage had been around for only a decade or two. By then it had spread to religiously, politically, racially, and so on, not just gender and sexuality.
For the census and most official government forms, it takes nothing to prove that your self-identification is valid… other than checking the box. Federal data on race and ethnicity is based upon self-identification, and nobody asks for proof. The official definition defines “Hispanic or Latino” as a person of Cuban, Mexican, Puerto Rican, South or Central American, or other Spanish culture or origin regardless of race. A few things follow from that. To begin with, “culture or origin” is broad. You don’t need to speak Spanish or have a set share of ancestry from 23andMe. It seems that a background from Spain counts. But, strangely, Brazil is usually left out because it is Portuguese-speaking, and so are people of non-Spanish European ancestry from places like Portugal or Italy…strange. Hispanic has always been an ethnicity, not a race, so a Hispanic person can be of any race. Race is usually tied to inherited physical traits, like skin color and facial features. Ethnicity is tied to shared culture of language, ancestry, religion, customs, and a sense of common origin. People are often sorted by race based on how they look. Ethnicity is more about what a group shares and practices. Historically, race was often assigned by others, through law, custom, or how strangers see you. Ethnicity is more often claimed and lived from the inside. Ethnicity can be partly gained or lost; descendants of immigrants assimilate, and people return to their roots. Race has historically been treated as fixed. One race can include many ethnicities. White Americans include Irish, Italian, and Polish Americans. And one ethnicity can include many races. Hispanics, for example, can be white, Black, Indigenous, or mixed. That’s why the census has long asked about the two separately. The catch is that scientists generally agree that race isn’t a clear biological category. Human genetic variation is gradual and mostly found within groups rather than between them. So most scholars call race a social construct. That doesn’t make it unimportant: it has had real effects through law and discrimination, like Jim Crow and the old and despicable “one-drop rule.” Ethnicity is cultural by definition, so it was never claimed to be biology in the first place. The line between them has also shifted over time. Irish and Italian immigrants were once described as separate “races” and are now seen as ethnic groups within “white.” A recent change came about in 2024 when the government began moving to a combined race/ethnicity question, which makes Hispanic one of the boxes next to White, Black, and the others. Part of the reason for that was that a large proportion of Hispanic or Latino respondents selecting Some Other Race. The Census Bureau plans to use the new format in the 2027 American Community Survey and the 2030 Census.
When money or benefits depend on it, the bar is higher. Minority-business certifications and some contracting programs usually ask for documents, such as birth records showing a parent or grandparent of Hispanic origin. The presumption was that there was a disadvantage for Hispanics. A 2023 federal court ruling ended that presumption, so applicants now have to show disadvantage individually. Falsely claiming the status to win a contract or a benefit can be fraud. Checking the box on a survey has no such consequences. Despite the fact that I say that I identify as Hispanic, I have never ticked the Hispanic box to gain any advantage whatsoever. I believe I qualify as a person of privilege and wouldn’t presume otherwise for any purpose. But still…having what I have always considered to be a Hispanic father (technically born in Italy, but coming of age in Venezuela), living for 6 of my first 7 years in Latin America, including attending a local, Hispanic Kindergarten, and speaking Spanish off and on my whole life (not well, but with a good native accent), I have always identified as at least somewhat Hispanic.
When I come to a place like Mexico for a week like this past week, I find myself constantly chatting up the locals we interact with (mostly the tour guides or hotel people) trying to portray myself as having a strong identity connection with them and their country. In the case of Mexico, I always mention my growing up in Venezuela and Costa Rica, of having a Hispanic father, of having a half-brother who was a local celebrity football announcer (a sensationalist play I seem to enjoy name-dropping…usually to very positive effect), and even of saying that my father built the first Camino Real Hotel (a popular landmark) here in CDMX in the 1960’s. That all must mean that I want to identify as Hispanic for one reason or another. Call it my Ich bin ein Berliner moment… Kennedy was my first elected President after all. Kennedy, who was talking in West Berlin, was declaring solidarity, of standing with the people of a walled-in city. He framed it with the Roman boast civis Romanus sum (“I am a Roman citizen”), saying the modern equivalent of that proud claim was Ich bin ein Berliner. Of course, some say he accidentally called himself a jelly doughnut, since a “Berliner” is also a pastry in Germany.
I have told Kim that I have thoroughly enjoyed our visit to Mexico. The blend of Malinalco and the CDMX has been just right. I connect to all aspects of the culture, the rural/indigenous, the anthropological/archeological, the urban design that blends indigenous and modern, the spirit of revolution and the tenuous balance of machismo and the divine feminine. We will come back and perhaps often now that we have “discovered” the CBX and wonders of Aeromexico. But just to keep me humble in my “Guatamalaness” as Hank Azaria said in The Birdcage, at lunch (with our most gracious hosts, John & Elaine), I headed off to the men’s room. I was surprised to be followed by a member of the wait staff. As I put my hand on the door with the big M on it, he stopped me and pointed to the other door and said in perfect English, “H is for hombres, señor”.

