Memoir

Dear John Abernathy

A “Dear John letter” is generally a letter from a wife or girlfriend ending the relationship. The phrase comes from American servicemen in World War II. It first shows up in print around 1945. John was one of the most common men’s names, so it worked as a stand-in for any soldier (i.e. John Doe). One popular explanation from that period is that the opening gave the bad news away: a letter that began with a cool “Dear John” rather than “Dearest Johnny” or “My darling” told the reader what was coming before he got to the second line. With millions of men overseas for years, many relationships at home ended, and the letters became a well-known part of military life. The origin isn’t certain. Some people link it to Dear John, a radio drama of the 1930s and ’40s starring actress Irene Rich, whose episodes opened with a letter to “John.” Others think the name was simply generic, the way John Doe is. The term spread after the war. During Korea, “A Dear John Letter,” was a 1953 duet by Jean Shepard and Ferlin Husky about a soldier getting one and it became a No. 1 country hit and made the phrase widely known. During Vietnam and after it stayed standard military slang. Units sometimes posted Dear John letters on a “wall of shame” to show solidarity with the men who got them. In everyday use it now means any breakup letter or, loosely, any blunt rejection. “Dear Jane” is the version sent to a woman. It always reminds me of that old joke about the G.I. (Abernathy) in basic training who’s mother dies and his hardened and inarticulate drill sergeant needs to break the bad news to him. Lacking any idea of how best to do it, he calls the troops to attention and then shouts at them, “Everyone with a mother, please step forward!” When the whole troop steps forward, he shouts, “Not so fast, Abernathy!”

This week I have been writing about our week in Mexico with my old business school friend, John and his wife Elaine. We are in the CDMX now and have a few more days of touring the sights and museums of this culturally diverse and fantastically social and inviting city that John & Elaine have called their alternative home for 25 years or more. While I have known John literally for 52 years, it has been one of those relationships that if mapped on an intimacy scale would have been intense for a few years (approximately 5), completely non-existent for 20 years, sporadic for 20 years, and closer but still only occasional for the past five years. At our 50th reunion last summer in Ithaca (a place I consider my ancestral home and a place he has made his primary residence for the past 45 years) we joked about getting together in Mexico since we live in San Diego and he has a home there that he wants to visit more often than he’s been able to for the past five years. In our own ways and for our own reasons we were both very serious about the get-together, so it came about pretty seriously and with no reservations that I could see on either side. John set the basic schedule for spending half the week in his home village of Malinalco and half the week in the CDMX. I made the travel plans. John set us up to be picked up at the airport and whisked to his Hacienda Jardin Magico in Malinalco (un Pueblo Magico extraordinaire). Kim arranged the CDMX tours through a hotel that John recommended. And John “sprinkled ChatGPT dust over the whole plan” and produced a wonderful illustrated itinerary for us for the week. Everything was all set and the Malinalco portion of the agenda came off magnificently.

Yesterday was our transition day. John & Elaine were ending a three-week stay at their Hacienda, so they had lots to do to gather up their lives and prepare to move their act, first to their daughter’s place in the CDMX, and then back to Ithaca. That gave Kim and I a chance for a leisurely stroll around the lovely ground of Hacienda Jardin Magico, and a chance to absorb the wonderful atmosphere of the Malinalco countryside. John was less engaged in the packing up than Elaine so he probably spent an hour or more of sitting and talking with me (of course, that’s in addition to all the talking we had done over the prior few days of walking around and driving around the village and archeological sites). Along the way I got in a good amount of time of talking to and getting to know Elaine (as did Kim on their various shopping sprees). I would characterize the visit as a solid chance to get to know about one another’s lives and families in a very intensive and intimate way, which was wonderful. We found lots and lots of things we unknowingly had in common beyond the obvious ones of having gone to school together, a shared friendship with “Gross Bob” from school, having started work for the same employer for several years and having both a shared history and life in Ithaca, Lansing and at Cornell, but also in the world of Latin America. During our two-hour car ride into CDMX with Luis at the wheel and the rest of us crowded in along with Cooper the pup, we told more stories of our lives and laughed our way into Mexico City. Then, while Elaine, Kim, and their daughter Tina went out for another shopping expedition, John and I sat and rested, as old guys tend to do, and it was during those two hours that everything changed.

John and I have both been pretty successful in our careers and in our lives, but we chose to follow very different paths. John has been married once to Elaine and they have four children; two girls and two boys. It took me three marriages to find Kim and I have two boys and a girl. Naturally, all of our kids went to Cornell and that makes his kids fourth generation Cornellians, where mine are third-generation. John’s oldest son has more or less the same job my oldest son had at the Johnson School when he lived in Ithaca for a few years. John’s youngest son is in the artistic and music production arena and he lives in Brooklyn. My youngest son lived in Brooklyn for a long time (he’s now in Denver) and is a video producer and, indeed an artistic sort. Neither of our boys have kids, but his daughters, one of whom runs marathons, both have kids and my daughter, who runs marathons, has two kids….and lives in Brooklyn. Two of my kids married Cornellians and the other married a woman from the Ithaca area. One of his daughters married an Ithaca area man and as for his sons, its early days, so who knows whether there’s a Cornell partner in their futures. The trials and tribulations of multiple home ownership, business relations and even parenthood has amazing commonality and touch points. We both even have a small furry dog at this point to keep us company in our empty nests. The common ground we found we share is not just extensive, it’s downright freaky. Our political views are similar, our worldview seems entirely consistent, and even our manner, as much as all that has evolved very separately for us each, is eirily the same. We aren’t quite finishing each other’s sentences this week, but we are doing that John Cleese and Monty Python “Four Yorkshiremen” bit where four well-off Yorkshiremen sit and start comparing how poor they were growing up. Each one tops the last. A single cramped room turns into a corridor, then a hole in the ground, then a cardboard box in the middle of the road, then a shoebox. And did you know that John Cleese was a Provost’s Visiting Professor at Cornell…several times!?

We expect to host John & Elaine in San Diego, see them in NYC or Ithaca, and maybe even plan a trip to China or somewhere exotic together. You can’t ignore the universe when it tells you that you have so much that you share in life. So, I say, “Dear John, not so fast, Abernathy, don’t be a stranger any more.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *